| Ideas ideas or main menu cosmology
Dualism Armed with such a view an enquirer ought to be better prepared to design experiments to investigate the phenomena, and better prepared to deal with both the rival claims and the over-reactions of religious and scientific fanatics.
The Elusiveness of the Paranormal The sensational characteristics of psychic phenomena, their apparent contradiction of the 'orthodox' laws of physics etc., repels consideration by traditional dualistic scientists. Unless the problem of subjectivity is properly understood then psychic phenomena will remain sporadic and unreproducable and therefore 'unscientific'. However, any lessons learned by understanding the nature of subjective influences on objective phenomena will almost certainly have a great impact on modern physicists who, after a hundred years, are still unable to integrate the role of subjectivity into their theoretical framework in spite of their realisation of the impact of the 'subjective observer' in both relativity theory and quantum theory.
Solipsism These assumptions are, that the observer has no memories which relate a contemporary observation to any previous ones, and that the observer has no interest in processing his or her sense data so as to formulate any abstract generalisations such as laws of Nature or laws of God. In other words the solipsist is completely impotent and has no wish to impose any order on, nor extract any order from raw sensation. The solipsist lives in a universe in which every event is a surprise. Nothing is learned and nothing can be taken for granted. If perpetuated for too long this view-point would become excruciatingly painful to maintain. However, even the possibility of such a philosophical position casts doubt on the substantiality of any observed object, since it is regarded as existing only so long as its observer wishes it to exist. This state of affairs bears an important resemblance to the insubstantiality of those psi events which occur only if the observer is receptive to them, that is so long as he or she subjectively 'permits' their existence or 'believes' in them.
The Impossibility of Objectivity Hence the Laws of Nature and the Laws of God ought to be regarded as subjectively created patterns used as models to measure and assess the value of observations of 'reality'. As such they are subject to change by authoritative theoreticians, whether they be prophets, priests, philosophers, scientists, artists or magicians. The content of observations is also controlled by these frameworks of laws since they act like filters in the mind of any observer, screening out those events which do not accord with the laws by relegating them to the status of a pseudo-science or pseudo-religion or suppressing them entirely. Thus a successful law of the Universe is like a self-fulfilling prophecy - it brings about the very observations which confirm the law, in a 'positive feedback loop'. One should not conclude from this that the laws of the Universe are created by each individual for their own exclusive use, rather they are the outcome of a cultural heritage, which no one person has the capacity to verify personally, following the path by which it was created. The Laws of the Universe formulated by a culture have to be learned, not experienced in their totality. They may be altered by persons with the prescribed cultural authority, provided the authority does not lose its influence, i.e. break its own charismatic spell, by proposing too drastic a change. Even absolute rulers must take account of the customs and usages of the land if they wish to survive.
The development and maintenance of the dominant reality may usefully be compared with the conditions required to maintain the deviant reality of a seance. The members of a seance represent a sub-culture or counter-culture which insists on, or at least encourages, the reality of certain events which are proscribed by the dominant culture. When such a sub-culture is able to shut out the influences of the outside world in a given space and time then its 'private' reality begins to manifest itself. In Jungian terms the 'collective unconscious' of the seance becomes detached from the 'collective unconscious' of the remainder of mankind. In order to achieve this detachment it is essential for the group to first exclude sceptics until their own power and self confidence has been sufficiently enhanced by the positive feedback of anticipated experiences to risk allowing the doubter to attempt to interfere with their convictions. It should be remembered that whilst sceptics are excluded it is impossible for an outsider to establish whether the events reportedly occurring in the seance are 'real', a 'hoax', or a 'delusion' manufactured by the converted. There is in this situation no difference between any of these labels. From the subjectivist point of view there can be no distinction between reality, hoax and delusion. What is 'real' for any human culture, including our own, could be logicially regarded as no more than a most elaborate hoax conjured up on a scale grand enough to convince a great many people.
Experimental Confirmation In this experiment the personal profile of the fictitious personality of a communicator spirit is created by a seance group, none of whom is a known medium. The personality of the spirit is then expected to perform raps on a table in response to questions and to answer according to the group's expectations of this personality. All of these expectations were fulfilled, with one exception: the answer to one question was decidedly the opposite of what had been anticipated. It may be that one or more members of the group unconsciously wished for this alternative answer rather than the agreed answer. Batchelor and Brookes-Smith (various private publications) have also performed many experimental seances, without known mediums, which created prearranged paranormal events such as raps, table lifting and messages. Interestingly they emphasise the role of humour in achieving the desired result, sometimes with spectacular success. It is interesting to note that the type of paranormal event expected in a seance or other psychic manifestation depends upon the dominant culture background against which the event is realised. Thus the Philippine psychic surgeons, who claimed to perform materially visible and bloody surgery with their bare hands, were responding to the local image of western medicine and capitalising on the curative mystique it has with simple folk. In England psychic healers are not expected to perform surgery, ritual or otherwise, to achieve an equivalent result.
Subjectivity and Established Reality A change or paradigm shift in the world view of a dominant culture operates very like the development of a seance or subculture until it becomes recognised as a respectable body of belief with recognised authorities. Indeed a research group, performing a crucial or speculative experiment, behaves very much like a seance group with their extreme caution, secrecy and hesitance until more confidence in the result is forthcoming. Historical accounts of the development of innovative conceptualisations show this very clearly. Freud's extreme caution is an excellent recent example as is that of Copernicus in an earlier period. The experimental seances described earlier are however insufficient to demonstrate the wider claim of the application of subjectivity ro the dominant reality. What is needed is an experiment which is effectively like an open seance, in which a hitherto paranormal event is created before a large audience which is not entirely convinced of the possibility, nor entirely opposed.
As previously stated, the basic form of the experiment is to create an heretical event (scientific heresy) before a large audience as a kind of public seance. The Wizard's principal skills in developing such an event are his spell-binding oratorical performances and, less obviously, his long-term, patient and unpaid assistance with the legitimate aims of established institutions. In order to generate the necessary audience interest and humorous scepticism the event selected ought to appeal to the popular imagination. It is also most useful to integrate the event with various myths derived from the dominant reality system, both to minimise rejection, and to focus together those elements of the dominant culture which lean favourably towards the event. The experiment supports the established reality along a train of development until it is strong enough to come to an unorthodox conclusion. In this respect it differs from most "alternative realities" by avoiding the energy wasted in total opposition to orthodox reality. The experiment was first formulated by the Wizard at Melbourne University in 1970 and was originally planned for 1974. Carefully detaching himself from from all economic, legal and moral dependence upon established institutions as Ian Channell, he was now known only as a fictional character, "The Wizard". With suitable and essential media coverage he planned to leave his New Zealand base in Christchurch and sail to Antipodes Island some 250 miles south-east of New Zealand, and the only point of land "Antipodean" to the English Channel. Once there, communications systems would be established to broadcast the event around the world. Then at the hour of his 42nd birthday, amidst a small crowd of witnesses (and after several hours of music and oratory giving his reasons why he was making the attempt) he would attempt to rise into the air (whence the need for levity) and vanish, subsequently reappearing and splashing down on the opposite side of the Earth at a point fifty miles south of the Isle of Wight where a fleet of small craft would be waiting to pick him up. The mood in which this experiment was to be conducted was in accord with the recommendations of Batcheldor and Brookes-Smith, for joviality and relaxation within an atmosphere of pleasurable expectancy; a non-dualistic synthesis of levity and levitation. The content of the experimental development integrates a number of British myths and imaginative tales. The journey to a distant island with the possibility of vanishing invokes Lewis Caroll's The Hunting of the Snark. It also has parallels with the disappearance of the keepers of the Flannen Light (see Mitchell's Flying Saucer Vision)and Dante's ascension from the earthly paradise. The ideas of levity, levitation and vanishing have the advantage of discouraging moral or other serious overtones which might appear with other paranormal events. Intellectual interest in ecstatic flight has increased with the recent interest in the therapeutic application of shamanistic powers and practices. As a parapsychology experiment even a partial result such as levitation would be of interest. The more spectacular result of appearing on the opposite face of the earth involves a considerably enlarged audience and provides a better test of the thesis that reality is fulfilled cultural expectation which can be moulded by respected authorities.
What Happened At the English Channel end I was able to organise several boats from Portsmouth but logistical problems and uncertain weather conditions made everything immensely difficult. What did happen in its place was a sudden explosion of interest and controversy surrounding the Wizard quite a different areas of activity. The interest has continued unabated ever since. It is still possible to carry out this experiment even in a modified form. The Wizard has considered making the attempt at any cosmologically significant site in the world, to which he is invited, provided he is given sufficient cooperative news coverage and resources to make the journey.
If this experiment were to prove successful then it would demonstrate the ultimately subjective nature of all reality, even orthodox scientific reality, by producing a major shift in reality i.e. the realization of levitation and teleportation, following a large scale mass-media seance. Instead of confining itself to a sub-culture or private reality, use is made of the dominant culture (the world's news services) thereby avoiding much of the fear-based secrecy of a traditional seance. Even if this "thought experiment" failed to fulfil expectations there would still be much to be learned by studying the cultural repercussions of the attempt which should have considerable impact on reality as maintained and communicated in our present civilization.
Dr. Derek Banks
|